October 18, 2026 – The Twenty-First Sunday After Pentecost

The Rev. Mary Davis

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable in your sight O Lord, my
strength and my Redeemer. Amen.
This morning, I’d like to dig deeper into today’s Gospel. But in order to do that, first, we need to go back in
time, 6 months ago or so, and remember Palm Sunday. Because, importantly, the timing for today’s
Gospel is smack in the middle of our Holy Week, and during the festival of the Jewish Passover. And the
location for this reading is inside the Temple, within the city of Jerusalem.
Of course, we all know how Holy Week ends . . . but let’s remember how it began . . . with a parade.
Actually with two parades.
First, there was Jesus’ parade. We like to call it Jesus’ “Triumphal entry” into Jerusalem, because he made
his grande entry through the eastern gates of the city, making that final transition from ‘country mouse’ to
‘city mouse,’ so to speak, riding on the back of a donkey. Jesus’ reputation for healing and preaching
about the coming of God’s kingdom had preceded him, so crowds of people showed up to hail his arrival.
They were desperately looking for liberation from the Roman empire, and Jesus had been tapped to carry
that baton.
Well, you should also know that at the same time that Jesus was arriving in Jerusalem from the east,
there was a simultaneous second parade going on – this one coming from the west of town. Only this
parade was a powerful display of Roman imperial power. Pontius Pilate, the Roman Governor of Judea
arrived sitting on his war horse, most likely a stallion – certainly not a lowly donkey – and he was flanked
and supported by hundreds and hundreds of heavily armed Roman soldiers. Make no mistake, this
second parade was very intentional. It was meant to be a show of force by the Empire, to stir up fear
among the visiting pilgrims in Jerusalem, and to provide a major disincentive for any kind of Jewish
rebellion.
How ironic was it that the Jewish population and scores of Jewish pilgrims were all gathered in Jerusalem
to celebrate their historical liberation from the Egyptians, while at the same time, they were still living
under the oppression of Roman rule.
Of course, these two parades symbolized the conflict between the Jewish population and the oppressive
Roman Empire, and part of that Roman oppression included paying taxes – and I don’t mean just a 10%
sales tax. I’m talking about a huge sum, enough to keep the Jewish people and other citizens of the region
locked in debt, despair, and poverty.
Well, just like there were two parades entering the frenzied city of Jerusalem, there were also two camps
of Jewish believers protesting Jesus’ movement. To no one’s surprise, the Jewish Pharisees weren’t too
keen on paying taxes to Caesar. They saw what a heavy burden it placed on their people and they wanted
to be freed from Roman rule over their lives.
2
Then there was another group of Jewish believers, a more secular group though, called the Herodians.
And as the name implied, they actually supported king Herod Antipas, but unlike the Pharisees, they
were fine with collecting the money on behalf of the empire . . . they were also fine with skimming some $
off the top of those tax collections.
So in today’s Gospel, it’s a little surprising to find such strange bedfellows, the Herodians and the
Pharisees, joining forces to trap Jesus. Because what both groups could agree on was that Jesus’
popularity and power were growing exponentially, and they wanted to shut that down.
Hence the question, “Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not,” – it was a damned if you do, damned
if you don’t type of question.
You see, to Pharisees, using the Roman coins, complete with the Emperor’s face and the words, “Long
live the Son of God” on it, was breaking at least one of the commandments of God – the “no graven
images” one, for a start. So if Jesus had answered, “yes, it is lawful to pay taxes to the emperor,” he would
have been breaking Jewish law.
But for the Herodians, who supported paying taxes to the Romans if Jesus had answered, “no, it’s not
lawful to pay taxes to the emperor,” he would have been breaking Roman law for seditious behavior and
been arrested IN THAT VERY MOMENT (remember, this was in the middle of Holy Week, so Jesus was
already being circled by leery authorities . . . and it was only 2 more days until he was actually arrested on
that charge).
So Jesus asked one of them to show him a coin, and said, “whose image is on it?” Of course, it was
Caesar’s, which is when Jesus gave them his famously sly answer, successfully avoiding their trap, “Give
to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s.”
This is the mic-drop point of this story, the part I hope you will take with you today. Because in that
moment, Jesus brings his critics – and us, today – back to the idea in Genesis 1, that EVERYTHING
created by God bears the image of God. Give to God what is God’s. That’s everything. And you’ll recall in
the creation story that all of it is GOOD.
3rd century father of Latin Christianity, Tertullian translated Jesus’ words like this: “Give to Caesar
Caesar’s image which is on the coin. Give to God, God’s image, which is on mankind.” And that’s the
point of this Gospel passage today. Yes, we are in the world, where empires rise and fall, where
authoritarians place their images on coins and hope to be worshipped, but more importantly – MOST
IMPORTANTLY – we are in the world where every human being has God’s divine inscription etched within
us. This where our worth lies. This is where our purpose lives. This is what gives us life!
Now, here’s the rub, of course. And I’m sure I can see the wheels in your minds spinning . . . but THIS
WORLD! This country? With this division? This evil? This corruption. This pain. This suffering. How can
THAT be GOOD?
3
For that, I want to tell you a story that takes me all the way back to the time when I was in Seminary. I
went to a Methodist School of Theology, named Drew University in New Jersey. And one of the hallmarks
of Methodist worship was this call and response, which went like this:
The pastor or leader would say, “God is Good.”
And the people would respond, “All the time.”
Then the leader would repeat, “All the time,”
and the people would say, “God is good.”
Well, my years in seminary just happened to be the same years that my youngest son was diagnosed on
the autism spectrum. And believe it or not, this was on the heels of my oldest son ALSO being diagnosed
with autism. So you can imagine, in my profound grief, this was very difficult time for me to hear “God is
Good, all the time, and all the time, God is good.” It felt like a slap in the face actually.
But then a seminary friend of mine went to a lecture by the Methodist Bishop of Sierra Leone. And I’m
sure you know that the people of Siera Leone had endured years and years of civil war. Not ‘only’ that, but
they were also besieged by the Ebola crisis. And not ‘only’ that, at the time, they were also facing
devasting mud slides. Imagine being the one to say, “God is good, all the time, and all the time, God is
good,” to the members of those communities. Well, a brave someone in the audience asked the Bishop
about this regular call and response. And in his compassion and wisdom, he said that in fact, given their
circumstances, they needed to modify the way they used that call and response. Not to deny the
goodness of God in any way, but to help them find their place within that goodness. So he would say,
“God is good,” and rather than respond with, “all the time,” the people would respond, “And I am a
witness.” God is good, and I am a witness. I am a witness, that God is good. And this became the rallying
cry for the people of Siera Leone, because it pointed them to the possibility – to the TRUTH – of beauty,
richness, and God’s grace, even in the midst of such horror.
And I think the truth to what Jesus’ answer to the Pharisees and Herodians was never about taxation.
Jesus was pointing out that this world is run on an economy of greed. To most of us, it looks like we
worship violence. There’s jockeying for power and influence that seems to be a zero-sum game. And the
oppressed and suffering are everywhere we turn. And yet, God is good, and we are witnesses.
So do not let Caesar’s world define you. Instead, remember that we are imprinted with the image of God,
and that God’s universal love remains alive in you. As we live and breathe, we are in the midst of sacred
space. We are in the midst of God’s goodness. And thanks be to God, we are witnesses. Amen.

Year A –  The Twenty-First Sunday after Pentecost  –  October 18, 2026   –  The Rev. Mary Davis